Look, I’m pro-fresh-herb. I love giant huge bunches of cilantro, I consider it a crime that parsley isn’t used as a vegetable, I’ll drink chimichurri sauce by the shot glass. Who has two thumbs and loves fresh herbs? This girl.
And yet – there is a place for dried herbs. Usually, that place involves a big pot of stew, a glass of red wine and slippers. Let’s explore.
Basic Dried Herb Substitution Rules
Use 1/3rd the volume of when substituting dried herbs for fresh.
- If a recipe calls for 1 tablespoon of chopped fresh basil, substitute 1 teaspoon of dried basil.
Going the other direction?
Use 3 times the volume when substituting fresh chopped herbs for dried.
- If a recipe calls for 1/2 teaspoon dried thyme, use 1 1/2 teaspoons fresh thyme.
Dried Herbs To Avoid
The flavor of all herbs changes somewhat when dried. But some herbs lose so much flavor when dried that they just aren’t worth using. These include:
Parsley, in particular, loses everything that makes it wonderful when subjected to dehydration. It’s also easy to grow and buy nearly year-round, so there’s really no excuse for dried parsley.
When a recipe calls for any of these fresh herbs, consider substituting something else, rather than reaching to the dried equivalent. For example, if a recipe calls for fresh chives but you don’t have any, don’t use dried chives. Dried chives suck. Instead, substitute green onions or finely minced shallot for a similar allium-vibe.
Dried Herbs That Aren’t That Bad
Fresh-herb-only purists don’t like to admit it, but some herbs hold their own quite well when dried. My most used dried herbs are:
- Bay Leaf
Now the great irony is that nearly all of these herbs are hardy enough to hold up all winter long in my Zone 7B/8A garden, so drying them can be a bit unnecessary. But I’ll be honest – in winter, sometimes I just don’t want to go tromping around cutting fresh thyme. I want to stay inside with my slippers on. So, dried thyme it is.
Tarragon is a bit controversial – you’ll see people saying it should be on the list above, the forbidden list. I disagree. I grow French Tarragon, and when dried gently it maintains a wonderful licoricey pungency. However, it’s delicate and does lose it’s flavor quickly. My advice? Grow your own or buy small amounts in bulk from someplace with a good, brisk herb and spice turnover.
Know When To Add Herbs
Dried herbs perform best in dishes with a long cooking time and a fair amount of liquid where they will simmer and rehydrate for some time. Dishes like stew, soups, braises, chili and long-simmering curries tend to do well with dried herbs.
Dried herbs are also a superior choice to fresh when you’re making a spice rub for long-cooked, smoked or barbecued meats or fish.
Most dried herbs should be added to your dish earlier in the cooking process than their fresh equivalents would be. This is especially true for leafy green herbs like basil, mint and oregano, which are nearly always added at the very end of cooking when fresh.
For the best flavor, consider briefly cooking dried herbs in a small amount of butter or oil to help bring out the fat-soluble flavor compounds before adding the herbs and cooking fat to the dish. (This is called “blooming” the herbs.) If your dish also includes spices, you should be doing this anyway – feel free to bloom the dried herbs and spices together.
One Last Thing
Dried herbs lose potency quickly, especially if stored where they are exposed to heat, sunlight, or oxygen. Keep your dried herbs in good shape longer by storing them in an airtight jar inside a cabinet or drawer. On the counter next to your stove might be convenient, but it’s a terrible place to store your dried herbs.
(Read more: How I store my herbs and spices.)